The legal and ethical challenges of gifting animals
Resum
The slogan “an animal is not a gift” seems quite obvious nowadays. However, the obviousness of this claim is not accompanied by a change in social practices, including the law. Indeed, the law does not prohibit the donation of an animal as a gift – animals can therefore be the ‘object’ of a donation contract. This leads to a number of legal and ethical challenges: with the acceptance of the ‘gift’ the recipient becomes responsible before the law for the animal’s fate. In turn, the giving of a gift is not necessarily accompanied by an explicit ‘acceptance of responsibility for the gift’ – traditionally, the giving of gifts is not associated with ‘responsibility’ but pleasure of recipient. The paper aims to present and evaluate the legal and ethical challenges of treating animals as a gift (as the object of a donation contract). To this end, the authors present key challenges posed by the application of contract law in such situations, specifically the donation contract, and then juxtapose the legal findings with an ethical view of the status of animals and their relationship to humans according to care ethics approach.
Paraules clau
donation, animal welfare, ethics of care, giftReferències
AMERICAN HUMANE ASSOCIATION (2013). Keeping Pets (Dogs and Cats) in Homes: A Three-Phase Retention Study. Retrieved from https://www.americanhumane.org/app/uploads/2016/08/petsmart-keeping-pets-phase-ii.pdf
ASPCA (2013). It’s Okay to Give Pets as Gifts. Really. Retrieved from https://www.aspca.org/about-us/press-releases/aspca-its-okay-give-pets-gifts-really
BENHABIB, S. (1985). “The Generalized and the Concrete Other: The Kohlberg-Gilligan Controvers and Feminist Theory”. PRAXIS International, 5(4), 402-424.
EAGAN, B. H.; GORDON, E. & PROTOPOPOVA, A. (2022). “Reasons for Guardian-Relinquishment of Dogs to Shelters: Animal and Regional Predictors in British Columbia, Canada”. Frontiers in veterinary science, 9, 857634. https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2022.857634
ENGSTER, D. (2006). “Care Ethics and Animal Welfare”. Journal of Social Philosophy, 37(4), 521-536.
FRANCIONE, G. (1996a). Rain without Thunder. An Ideology of the Animal Rights Movement. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
FRANCIONE, G. (1996b). “Ecofeminism and Animal Rights: A Review of Beyond Animal Rights: A Feminist Ethic for the Treatment of Animals”. Women’s Rights Law Reporter, 18(1), 97.
FRANCIONE, G. (2008). Animals as Persons. Essays on the Abolition of Animal Exploitation. New York: Columbia University Press.
GIMENEZ-CANDELA, M. (2022). “Animal Law: What Is Left to be Said by the Law About Animals”. In VITALE, A. & POLLO, S. (eds.). Human/Animal Relationships in Transformation. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, 363. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-85277-1_17
GOETTEL, M. (2013). Sytuacja zwierzęcia w prawie cywilnym. Warszawa: Lex a Wolters Kluwer business.
JENSEN, J.; SANDOE, P. & NIELSEN, S. S. (2020). “Owner-related reasons matter more than behavioural problems – a study of why owners relinquished dogs and cats to a Danish animal shelter from 1996 to 2017”. Animals, 10(6), 1064. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10061064
KANCLERZ, A. (2018). “Etyka troski Carol Gilligan i Nel Noddings a moralny partykularyzm”. Etyka, 57, 34.
KURKI, V. A. (2024). “A Bird’s-Eye View of Animals in the Law”. Modern Law Review, 87(6), 1452-1479. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2230.12886
LE BOT, O. (2011). “Les grandes évolutions du régime juridique de l’animal en Europe : constitutionnalisation et déréification”. Revue québécoise de droit international, 24(1), 254-256.
LE BOT, O. (2023). Constitutional Animal Law. Paris: Independently published.
ŁĘTOWSKA, E. (1997). “Dwa cywilnoprawne aspekty praw zwierząt: dereifikacja i personifikacja”. In SZPUNAR, A. (ed.). Studia z prawa prywatnego. Księga pamiątkowa ku czci profesor Biruty Lewaszkiewicz-Petrykowskiej. Łódź: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego, 71-92.
LUBELSKA-SAZANÓW, M. (2020). Animals as specific objects of obligations under Polish and German law. Göttingen: V&R unipress.
MATUSIK, G. in K. OSAJDA (ed.) (2017). Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz. Tom II. Własność i inne prawa rzeczowe, Ustawa o księgach wieczystych i hipotece (Artykuły 2-22, 65-1111), Ustawa o zastawie rejestrowym i rejestrze zastawów. Warszawa, p. 7.
MICHEL, M. (2023). “Moving Away from Thinghood in Law. Animals as a New Legal Category”. Journal of Animal Law, Ethics and One Health (LEOH), 29-43. https://doi.org/10.58590/leoh.2023.003
PETERS, A. (2016). “Vom Tierschutzrecht zu Legal Animal Studies: Forschungsdesiderate und Perspektiven”. Rechtswissenschaft, 328-331. https://doi.org/10.5771/1868-8098-2016-3-325
PIETRZYKOWSKI, T. (2023). Foundations of Animal Law. Katowice: University of Silesia Press.
PIETRZYKOWSKI, T. & LUBELSKA-SAZANÓW, M. (forthcoming). “Legal dereification of animals”. In PIETRZYKOWSKI, T. & WAHLBERG, B. (eds.). Research Handbook of Animal Law and Animal Rights (2025, forthcoming).
SAFJAN, M., in K. PIETRZYKOWSKI (ed.). Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz. Warszawa, p. 863;
SCARLETT, J. M.; SALMAN, M. D.; NEW, J. G. & KASS, P. H. (1999). “Reasons for relinquishment of companion animals in U.S. animal shelters: selected health and personal issues”. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 2(1), 41-57. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327604jaws0201_4
SLOTE, M. (2007). The Ethics of Care and Empathy. New York: Routledge.
STUCKI, S. (2016). Grundrechte für Tiere: Eine Kritik des geltenden Tierschutzrechts und rechtstheoretische Grundlegung von Tierrechten im Rahmen einer Neupositionierung des Tieres als Rechtssubjekt. Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft.
TRONTO, J. (1998). “An Ethic of Care”. Generations: Journal of the American Society on Aging, 22(3), 15-20. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/44875693
ULIŃSKI, M. (2012). Etyka troski i jej pogranicza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Aureus.
WEISS, E.; DOLAN, E. D.; GARRISON, L.; HONG, J. & SLATER, M. (2013). “Should Dogs and Cats be Given as Gifts?”. Animals, 3(4), 999.
WELLS, D. L. (2009). “The Effects of Animals on Human Health and Well-Being”. Journal of Social Issues, 65(3), 523-543.
WRANGE, B. (2022). “Caring animals and care ethic”. Biology & Philosophy, 37(18), 3.
Publicades
Descàrregues
Drets d'autor (c) 2024 Malgorzata Lubelska-Sazanow, Marlena Drapalska-Grochowicz
Aquesta obra està sota una llicència internacional Creative Commons Reconeixement 4.0.
