Emile Littré and the death of Alexander the Great
A philological and medical reappraisal
Abstract
The French philologist Émile Littré (1801-1881) is credited by several scholars as the first to propose that Alexander the Great died of malaria. This article demonstrates that this opinion of traditional origin is unsupported by Littré's scholarly production. He published only two full papers on the topic of Alexander's death, the first in 1844 and the latter in 1853. In both works he stated that Alexander died of a pseudo-continuous fever, that is, a long lasting fever characterized by initial phases of remission to become continuous at the end. This feverish pattern differed from that of intermittent fever of malarial type that Littré described in his medical Dictionary. The articles of 1865, 1872 and 1927 were reprints of the 1853 article. The 1927 version published in Æsculape was preceded by a preface in which the anonymous author arbitrarily introduced the new word “paludisme”, giving rise to the erroneous belief that has been handed down to date.
Keywords
Émile Littré, Alexander the Great, malaria hypothesis, pseudo-continuous feverReferences
ANTELA-BERNÁRDEZ, B., SIERRA MARTIN, C. (2018): "Alexander and the Medicine", Karanos 1: 35-54. https://doi.org/10.5565/rev/karanos.10
AQUARONE, S. (1958): The life and works of Émile Littré, Leyden.
BERTOLOTTI, M. (1932): Alessandro Magno, Torino.
BORZA E.N., REAMES-ZIMMERMAN, J., (2000): "Some new thoughts on the death of Alexander the Great", Ancient World 31: 22-30.
BRYANT, J.H. (1894): "One hundred cases of hyperpyrexia" in W. WHITE HALE, W.H.A JACOBSON (eds.): Guy's Hospital Reports vol. I, London: 385-572.
BUFANO, M. (1949): Trattato di Patologia speciale medica e terapia, Milano.
CASTIGLIONI, A. (1948): Storia della Medicina. Vol. II, Verona.
CHUGG, A. (2007), The quest for the tomb of Alexander the Great, AMC Publications.
CILLIERS, L., RETIEF, F.P., (1999): "The death of Alexander the Great", Acta Academica 31: 63-76
CITATI, P. (2004): Alessandro Magno, Milano.
CROTTI, D. (2005): "La Malaria, ossia la mal'aria: brevi note di una storia sociale e popolare", Le Infezioni in Medicina 4: 265- 270.
CUNHA, B. A. (2004): "The death of Alexander the Great: malaria or typhoid fever?", Infectious Diseases Clinics of North America 18(1): 53-63. https://doi.org/ 10.1016/S0891-5520(03)00090-4.
CUNHA C.B., (2007): "Prolonged and perplexing fevers in antiquity: malaria and typhoid fever", Infectious Diseases Clinics of North America 21: 857-866. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.idc.2007.08.010
DAMIANI, E. (2012): La piccola morte di Alessandro il Grande, Venezia.
DAMIANI, E., ELICE, M,., PECA CONTI, R. (2021): "The terminal aphonia of Alexander the Great, a silent herald of an ordinary death", Acta Medico-Historica Adriatica 18(2): 201-228. https://doi.org/10.31952/amha.18.2.1
DAREMBERG, G. (1882): "L'œuvre médicale de M. Littré", Revue des deux mondes 52(3): 634-671.
DECHAMBRE, A. (1878): Dictionnaire encyclopédique des sciences medicales, Paris.
DESTAING, F. (1970): "The death of Alexander", Presse Medicale 78: 2391-2393.
ENGELS, D. (1978): "A note on Alexander's death", Classical Philology 73: 224 -228. https://doi.org/10.1086/366434
FOUQUET, H. (1804): "Sur la fièvre qui se meut par jours pairs, et sur la nature del la maladie d'Alexandre", Recueil Périodique de la Société de Médecine de Paris redigé par Sedillot, T. 21: 290-300.
GARRISON, F. H. (1929): An introduction to the History of Medicine, Philadelphia and London.
GOVAERTS-REGIS, J. (1941) : Un Médecin au service de l'histoire. Augustin Cabanès, Paris.
GROTE, G. (1856): History of Greece, New York.
HALPERIN, E.C. (2006): "What or Who Killed Alexander the Great?", The Pharos summer: 19-25.
HEILBRON, J. (2007): "Sociologie et positivisme en France au XIX siècle: les vicissitudines de la Société de sociologie (1872-1874) ", Revue Française de sociologie 2 (48): 307-331. https://doi.org/10.3917/rfs.482.0307
LE DANTEC, F.A. (1901): Le paludisme, sa prophylaxie, Paris.
LIAPPAS, I., LASCARATOS, J., FAFOUTI, S., CHRISTODOULOU, G. (2003): "Alexander the Great's relationship with alcohol", Addiction 98(5): 561-567. https;//doi.org/10.1046/j.1360-0443.2003.00384.x
LITTRE, É. (1840): Oeuvres complètes d'Hippocrate. Vol. II, Paris.
LITTRE, É. (1844): "Sur la maladie d'Alexandre le Grand", in L. DE SINNER, Plutarque, Vie d'Alexandre, Paris: 133-138.
LITTRE, É. (1853): "De la science des poisons considérée dans l'histoire", Revue des deux mondes 4: 665-687.
LITTRE, É. (1839-1861): Œuvres complètes d'Hippocrate, reprinted 1961-1962, Amsterdam.
LITTRE, É. (1865): La vérité sur la mort d'Alexandre le Grand, Paris.
LITTRE, É. (1872): "De la toxicologie dans l'histoire et de la mort d'Alexandre", in E. LITTRE, Médecine et Médecins, Paris: 393-428.
LITTRE, É. (1927): "La mort d'Alexandre le Grand", Æsculape 17 : 222-228.
LOOMIS, A.L. (1884): Textbook of practical medicine, New York.
MACAULAY, A. (1831): A dictionary of medicine, designed for popular use, Edinburgh.
MAILLOT, F.C. (1838): Traité des fièvres ou irritations cérébro-spinales intermittentes; d'après les observations recuillies en France, en Corse, et en Afrique, Paris.
MOULOPOULOS S.D. (1998): "Letter to the Editor: A mysterious death", New England Journal of Medicine 339: 1248. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199810223391716
MULLER, K. (1846): "Arriani Anabasis et Indica, Paris:.
OLDACH, D.W., RICHARD, R.E., BORZA, E.N., BENITEZ, R.M. (1998a): "A mysterious death", New England Journal of Medicine 338: 1764-1769 (https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199806113382411). https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199806113382411
OLDACH, D.W, RICHARD, R.E., BORZA, E.N., BENITEZ, R.M. (1998b): "Letter to the Editor: A mysterious death: The authors reply", New England Journal of Medicine 339: 1249.
PACKARD, R.M. (2021): The making of a tropical disease: a short history of malaria, Baltimore. https://doi.org/10.56021/9781421441801
RADET, G. (1931): Alexandre le Grand, Paris.
RETIEF, F.P., CILLIERS, L. (2006): "The death of Alexander the Great", Acta Theologica 26 (2) Supplementum: 7, 29-4. https://doi.org/10.4314/acta.v.26i2.52557
ROSANELLI, C. (1870): Manuale di Patologia generale, Padova.
ROUSSILLE-CHAMSERU, J.F.J. (1798): "Observations médicales, extraites d'auteurs non médecins, appliquées à la description des fièvres subintrantes, et devant faire partie d'un plus grand travail", Mémoires de la Société Médicale d'émulation, 1 : 4-23.
SALLARES, R., (1991): The ecology of the ancient Greek world, New York.
SALTERINI, G. (1904): Il progresso terapeutico. Annuario Pratico Scientifico per l'anno 1904, Milano.
STAHULJAK, Z. (2013): "History as a Medical Category: Heredity, Positivism, and the Study of the Past in the Nineteenth-Century France", History of the Present 3(2): 140-159. https://doi.org/10.5406/historypresent.3.2.0140
WUNDERLICH, C. R. (1868): Das Verhalten der Eigenwärme in Krankheiten, Leipzig.
WUNDERLICH, C. R. (1871): On the Temperature in diseases: a manual of medical thermometry, London.
Published
How to Cite
Downloads
Copyright (c) 2024 Ernesto Damiani
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
