Origin and forms of regulation in the construction of American administrative law
Abstract
The origin of the regulation is analyzed from a point of view opposed to the classic normative intervention of the continental-French administrative State, that is, we refer to the original model of the United States of community-centric influence, as well as the implications that this other regulatory system will have in the rest of the world. For this, the role of social movements, at the beginning of the 20th century, in the appearance of different forms of regulation through their demands is highlighted. Likewise, regulatory systems are exposed that prioritize the mechanisms of self-regulation, disclosure and outcropping of information, evaluation, comparison, emulation, encouragement or reputation. For this reason, the notion of regulation can never be the Anglo-Saxon translation of our concept of administrative regulation, but rather a more complex, broad and dynamic instrument of intervention, as we will see below.
Keywords
United States, administrative regulation, citizen movements, rights, community, activism, litigation, prevention, risks, securityReferences
ACKERMAN, J. et al. (2006), «The global explosion of freedom of information laws», Administrative Law Review.
AMAN, A. (2006-2007), «Law, markets and democracy: A role for law in the neo-liberal state», New York Law School. L.R.
AMIR, O. y LOBEL, O. (2008), «Stumble, Predict, Nudge: How behavioral economics informs law and policy», Colum. L. Rev., 108.
BALLBÉ, M. y MARTÍNEZ, R. (2003), Soberanía dual y Constitución integradora: La reciente doctrina federal de la corte suprema norteamericana, Barcelona, Ariel.
BALLBÉ, M. y PADRÓS, C. (2001), «Spanish independent authority and its role in a new competitive environment», en G. AMATO (ed.), The anticompetitive impact of regulation, Edward Elgar.
BARZELAY, M. (1992), Breaking throught the Bureaucracy: A new vision for managing in government, Berkeley, University of California Press.
BARZELAY, M. (2001), The New Public Management, University of California Press.
BARZILAY, A. R. (2008), «Women at work: Towards and inclusive the narrative of the rights of the regulatory state», Harvard Journal of Law and Gender, invierno.
BERNSTEIN, D. (2012), Rehabilitating Lochner: Defending individual rights against progressive reform, University of Chicago Press.
BILDER, M. S. (2017), Madison’s hand. Revising the Constitutional Convention, Columbia.
BOBBITT, P. (2003), The Shield of Achilles: War, Peace and the course of History, Nueva York, Anchor Books.
BORIS, E. (2008), «Labor’s welfare state: Defining workers, constructing citizens», en M. GROSSBERG y C. TOMLINS (eds.), The Cambridge History of Law in America, vol. III, p. 332.
BRAITHWAITE, J. y DRAHOS, P. (2000), Global Business Regulation, Cambridge University Press.
BRANDEIS, L. D. (1914). Other People’s Money and How the Bankers Use It. New York, Frederick A. Stokes.
BRESSMAN, L. y VANDENBERGH, M. (2006), «Inside the administrative state: A critical look at the practice of presidential control», Michigan Law Review, núm. 105.
BREUNUNG, L. y NOCKE, J. (1994), «Environmental Officers: A viable concept for Ecological Management?», en G. TEUBNER, L. FARMER y D. MURPHY, Environmental Law and Ecological Responsibility: The Concept and Practice of Ecological Self-Organization, Wiley and Sons.
BREYER, S., STEWART, R., SUNSTEIN, C. y SPITZER, M. (2002), Administrative law and regulatory policy, Aspen Law and Business.
BROWN, P. (2007), Toxic exposures: Contested illnesses and the environmental health, Columbia University Press.
COURVILLE, S., PARKER, C. y WATCHIRS, H. (1997), «Introduction: Auditing in regulatory perspective», Law and Policy, vol. 25(3) (julio).
DEILY, M. y GRAY, W. (2007), «Agency structure and firm culture: Osha, EPA and the steel industry», Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, núm. 23.
DERTHICK, M. y QUIRK, P. (1985), The politics of deregulation, The Brookings Institute.
DUDZIAK, M. (2008), «Making law, making war, making America», en M. GROSSBERG y C. TOMLINS (eds.), The Cambridge History of Law in America, vol. III, p. 703.
EDELMAN, L. et al. (1991), «Legal ambiguity and the politics of compliance: Affirmative action officer’s dilemma», Law and Policy, vol. 13(1), p. 78.
EDELMAN, L. et al. (1999), «Legal ambiguity and the politics of compliance: Affirmative action officer’s dilemma», Law and Policy, vol. 13, núm. 1 (enero).
EPSTEIN, R. (2006), How progressives rewrote the Constitution, Cato Institute.
EPSTEIN, R. (2008), «The neoclassical economics of consumer contracts», 92 Minn.L.Rev., núm. 803.
ERICSON, R. (2007), Crime in an insecure world, Polity.
ERICSON, R. y HAGGERTY, K. (eds.) (1997), Policing the risk society, Oxford University Press.
ESKRIDGE, W. (2002), «Some effects of identity-based social movements on constitutional law in the Twentieth century», Michigan Law Review, vol. 100.
FISHER, L. (2003), «The rise of the risk commonwealth and the challenge for administrative law», Public Law, p. 445.
FLORINI, A. (ed.) (2007), The Right to Know: Transparency for an Open World, Columbia, con el prólogo de J. E. Stiglitz.
FREEMAN, J. (2003), «Extending public law norms through privatization», Harvard Law Review, núm. 116.
GLIMCHER, P. (2004), Decisions, Uncertainty, and the Brain: The Science of Neuroeconomics, MIT Press.
GRAHAM, J. (2008), «Saving lives through administrative law and economics», University of Pennsylvania Law Review (diciembre).
GUAYO CASTIELLA, I. del (2017), Regulación, Madrid, Marcial Pons.
GUTIÉRREZ RODRÍGUEZ, E. (2021), Emociones y género en la Era del Plástico: Implosión reguladora, Universo de Letras.
HAMILTON, J. (2005), Regulation through revelation, Cambridge University Press.
HARLOW, C. y RAWLINGS, R. (1992), Pressure Through law, Londres y Nueva York, p. 76-77.
HAWKINS, K. y THOMAS, J. (ed.) (1983), Enforcing regulation, Kluwer Pub.
PHILLIPS, H. (2000), en J. MAXWELL et al., «Self-regulation and social welfare: The political economy of corporate environmentalism», Journal of Law and Economics, 43 (octubre), p. 583.
JIMÉNEZ TELLO, P. (2009), Auditoría Universitaria y Calidad: La evaluación como conquista social ante la competencia universitaria global, VDM Verlag.
JOHNSTONE, R. y MITCHELL, R. (2004), «Regulating Work», en C. PARKER, C. SCOUT, N. LACEY y J. BRAITWAITE (ed.), Regulating law, Oxford, p. 101.
KAGAN, E. (2001), «Presidential Administration», Harvard Law Review, 114.
KAGAN, R. (1983), «On regulatory inspectorates and police», en K. HAWKINS y J. THOMAS (ed.), Enforcing regulation, Kluwer Pub.
KAHAN, D., SLOVIC, P., BRAMAN, D. y GASTIL, J. (2006), «Fear of democracy: A cultural evaluation of Sunstein Risk», Harvard Law Review, 119, p. 1071.
KAHN, A. (2008), «The Threat of latter-day progressives to an authentically liberal economic policy», Reg-Markets Center (enero).
KATZEN, S. (2007), «A reality check on an empirical study: Comments on “Inside the Administrative State”», Mich.L.Rev, 105.
KREIME, S. (2008), «The FOIA and the ecology of transparency», University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law, 10, p. 1011
LANDIS, J. (1941), The administrative process, Yale University Press.
LANDY, M., ROBERTS, M. y THOMAS, S. (1994), The environmental protection agency: Asking the wrong questions: From Nixon to Clinton [edición ampliada].
LUMPKIN, M. et al. (2006), «The FDA goes global», FDA Consumer, vol. 40, p. 68 y ss.
MAASSARANI, T. (2007), «Extracting corporate responsibility: Towards a human rights impact assessment», Cornell Int’l L.J., vol. 40, p. 135.
MARTIN, J. (2002), Nader-Crusader-Spoiler-Icon, Perseus Publishing.
MASHAW, J. (2012), Creating the administrative Constitution: The lost one hundred years of American Administrative Law, Yale University Press.
MAYER, D. (2009), «The myth of laissez-faire constitutionalism: Liberty of contract during the Lochner Era», Hastings Const. L. Q., núm. 36 (invierno).
MCGRAW, T. (1984), Prophets of Regulation, Belknap Harvard.
MCNOLLGAST (1999), «The Political origins of the Administrative Procedure Act», Journal of Law Economics and Organizations, vol. 15.
MÉNY, Y. (1994), La corruption de la République, París.
MONTERO PASCUAL, J. J. (2018). Regulación Económica, 3.ª ed., Valencia, Tirant lo Blanch.
MORALES PLAZA, A. (2009), La regulación nuclear globalizada, La Ley-Wolters Kluwer.
MOYNIHAN, D. P. (1992), On the law of nations, Harvard.
MYRES, S. (1986), Westering Women and the frontier experience 1800-1915, University of New Mexico Press, p. 215.
NADER, R. (2002), Crashing the party: Taking on the corporate government in an age of surrender, Thomas Dunne Books.
OBAMA, B. (1990), «Why organize?: Problems and promise in the inner city», en P. KNOEPFLE (ed.), After Alinsky: Community organizing in Illinois, Sangamon State University.
OBAMA, B. (2004), Dreams of my father, Three Rivers Press.
PADRÓS, C. y ROCA, J. (1995), «La armonización judicial en el control de la Administración: El papel del Tribunal Europeo de Derechos Humanos», RAP, núm. 136.
PARKER, R. (2006), «The empirical roots of the regulatory reform movement: A critical appraisal», Administrative Law Review, 58, p. 359 (primavera).
PECHMAN, C. (1994), Regulating power: The economics of electricity in the information age, Boston, p. 178.
PECKHAM, J. (1905), Opinion of the Court, Lochner v. New York, núm. 292.
PESTRITTO, R. (2007), «The progressive origins of the administrative state: Wilson, Goodnow, and Landis», Social Philosophy and Policy, vol. 24
PONCE, J. (2005), «Good administration and administrative procedures», Ind.J.Global Legal Stud., núm. 12.
POST, R. (2005), «Affirmative action and higher education: The view from somewhere», Yale Law and Policy Review, núm. 23.
POWER, M. (1999), The Audit Society: Rituals of Verification, Clarendon Press.
POWER, M. (2004), The risk management of everything: Rethinking the politics of uncertainty, Londres, Demos.
POWER, M. (2005), «Organizational responses to risk: The rise of the chief officer», en HUTTER et al. (ed.), Organizational encounters with Risk, Cambridge.
RABKIN (1980), «Office for Civil Rights», en J. WILSON (ed.), The Politics of Regulation, Harper, p. 305.
REVESZ, R., SANDS, P. y STEWART, R. (2001). Environmental Law the economy and sustainable development: The United States, the European Union and the International Community, Cambridge University Press.
ROBERTS, A. (2006), Blacked Out: Government secrecy in the information age, Cambridge.
SCHLOZMAN, K. y TIERNEY, J. (1986), Organized Interests and American Democracy, Nueva York, p. 342.
SELIGMAN, J. (1982), The transformation of Wall Street: A history of the Securities and Exchange Commission and modern corportate finance, Houghton Mifflin Co.
SHILLER, R. (2008), The subprime solution, Princeton UP, p. 134.
SIEGEL, R. (2006), «Constitutional culture, social movements conflict and constitutional change: the case of the de facto era», California Law Review (octubre).
SILBER, W. L. (2007), When Washington shut down Wall Street: The Great Financial Crisis of 1914 and the origins of America’s Monetary Supremacy, Princeton University Press.
STEWART, R. (1975), «The reformation of american administrative law», Harvard Law Review, vol. 88.
STONE, C. (1975), Where the law ends: The social control of corporate behavior, Harper Torchbooks.
STRUM, P. (1995), Brandeis on Democracy, U. P. Kansas.
SUNSTEIN, C. (1985), «Interest groups in American Public Law», Stanford Law Review, vol. 38, 29.
SUNSTEIN, C. (1987), «Constitutionalism after the New Deal», Harvard Law Review, 101, p. 450.
SUNSTEIN, C. (1993), After the rights revolution: Reconceiving the regulatory state, Harvard University Press.
SUNSTEIN, C. (2002), The cost-benefit state: The future of regulation protection, ABA.
SUNSTEIN, C. (2004), Risk and Reason: Safety, Law, and the Environment, Cambridge University Press, p. 258.
SUNSTEIN, C. y KAHNEMAN, D. (2000), Behavioral Law and Economics, Cambridge.
SUSMAN, T. (2006), «Lobbyng in the 21st Century-Reciprocity and the need for reform», Administrative Law Review, 58, fall.
THALER, R. y SUNSTEIN, C. (2008a), Nudge: Improving decisions about health, weath, and happiness, Yale U. P., p. 190.
THALER, R. y SUNSTEIN, C. (2008b), «Economic policy for humans», Boston Globe (17 de abril).
THORNDIKE, J. (2001), «Reforming the Internal Revenue Service: a comparative history». Administrative Law Review, vol. 50, p. 719.
VISCUSI, W. (2002), Regulation through Litigation, AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies.
VOGEL, D. (2005), The market for virtue: The Potential and Limits of Corporate Social Responsibility, Brookings.
WILLIAMS, C. (1999), «The Securities and Exchange Commission and corporate social transparency», Harvard Law Review, 112, p. 1209.
WILLIAMS, C. (2007), «Safe but not wholesome: The troubling state of trans fat regulation», Journal of Food Law and Policy.
Published
How to Cite
Downloads
Copyright (c) 2023 Manuel Ballbé Mallol, Roser Martínez Quirante
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
