Collective-Distributive Interpretations in Bilingual Spanish-English-Speaking Children
Developmental semantic research in child Italian, Spanish, and English has shown that children’s knowledge of distributive interpretations does not appear adult-like until 10 or 11 years of age. Further, children’s knowledge of distributive interpretations predicts their knowledge of collective interpretations. Lexical development, in these studies, predicts both their distributive and collective interpretations, while development of the inhibition component of executive function predicts children’s collective interpretations, but not their distributive interpretations. In this project, we test Spanish distributive and collective interpretations in a sample of bilingual Spanish-English-speaking 1st graders and an age- matched sample of monolingual Spanish-speaking children in Mexico. We find that the bilingual children have significantly greater inhibition scores than the monolingual children. The monolingual children, in contrast, have greater lexical scores than the bilinguals. Further results show that the monolinguals have more adult-like distributive and collective interpretations than do the bilinguals and that lexical scores are predictive of distributive- collective interpretations in the combined sample, while inhibition is not. We conclude that lexicon plays a greater role in collective implicature interpretations than does inhibition.
Keywordsdistributive, collective, scalar implicature, bilingual, pragmatics, semantics
Antoniou, Kyriakos., & Katsos, Napoleon. 2017. The Effect of Childhood Multilingualism and Bilectalism on Implicature understanding. Applied Psycholinguistics 38: 787-833. https://doi.org/10.1017/S014271641600045X
Baghbanian, Rezvan. 2021. Multiple Measures of Numerical Cognition and Quantifier Interpretation. Senior Honors Thesis. The Ohio State University.
Ben-Zeev, Sandra. 1977. The Influence of Bilingualism on Cognitive Strategy and Cognitive Development. Child Development 14.
Bialystok Ellen, Craik Fergus, Luk Gigi. 2012. Bilingualism: Consequences for Mind and Brain. Trends Cognitive Science 16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2012.03.001
Bialystok, Ellen, & Luk, Gigi. 2012. Receptive Vocabulary Differences in Monlingual and Bilingual Adults. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 15(2): 397-401. https://doi.org/10.1017/S136672891100040X
Bialystok, Ellen, Luk, Gigi, Peets, Kathleen, & Yang, Sujin. 2010. Receptive vocabulary differences in monolingual and bilingual children. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 13(4): 525-531. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1366728909990423
Boland, Julie, & Cutler, Anne. 1996. Interaction with Autonomy: Multiple Output Models and the Inadequacy of the Great Divide. Cognition 58(3): 309-320. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0277(95)00684-2
Brooks, Patricia & Braine, Martin. 1996. What Do Children Know about the Universal Quantifiers all and each? Cognition, 60(3): 235-268.
Brooks, Patricia, Jia, Xiangdong, Braine, Martin, & Dias, Maria. 1998. A Cross-Linguistic Study of Children's Comprehension of Universal Quantifiers: A Comparison of Mandarin Chinese, Portuguese and English. First Language, 18(1(52)): 33-79.
Crain, Stephen, & McKee, Cecile. 1985. The acquisition of structural restrictions on anaphora. Paper presented at the NELS 15, Amherst, University of Massachusetts.
Czapka Sophia, Wotschack Christiane, Klassert Annegret, & Festman Julia. 2020. A Path to the Bilingual Advantage: Pairwise Matching of Individuals. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 23: 344–354. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1366728919000166
De Houwer, Annick, Bornstein, Marc, & Putnick, Diane. 2014. A Bilingual-Monolingual Comparison of Young Children’s Vocabulary Size: Evidence from Comprehension and Production. Applied Psycholinguistics 35(6): 1189-1211. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0142716412000744
de Koster, Anna, Dotlačil, Jakub, & Spenader, Jennifer. 2017. Children's Understanding of Distributivity and Adjectives of Comparison. Paper presented at the 41st Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development.
de Koster, Anna, Spenader, Jennafer, & Hendriks, Petra. 2018. Are Children's Overly Distributive Interpretations and Spreading Errors Related? Paper presented at the 42nd Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development.
de Koster, Anna, Spenader, Jennifer, & Dotlačil, Jakub, & Hendriks, Petra. 2020. A Multiple Cue Explanation of Collective Interpretations with each. Paper presented at the 44th Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development.
de Koster, Anna, Hendriks, Petra & Spenader Jennifer. 2021. Child-Like Adults: Dual-Task Effects on Collective vs. Distributive Sentence Interpretations. Frontiers in Psychology 10. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.556120
Dotlačil, Jakub. 2010. Anaphora and distributivity: A study of same, different, reciprocals and others. (PhD Doctoral Dissertation), Utrecht Institute for Linguistics, OTS, LOT Series, Utrecht.
Dunn, Lloyd., Lugo, Delia, Padilla, Eligio, & Dunn, Leota. 1986. Test de Vocabulario en Imágenes Peabody [Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test]. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Services.
Eriksen, Barbara, Eriksen, Charles. 1974. Effects of noise letters upon the identification of a target letter in a nonsearch task. Perception & Psychophysics 16: 143–149. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03203267
Frazier, Lyn, Patch, Jeremy, & Rayner, Keith. 1999. Taking on Semantic Commitments, II: Collective versus Distributive Readings. Cognition 70: 87–104.
Fogel, Maiah. 2020. Dialect Variation, Multiple Measures of Inhibition, and Collective- Distributive Quantifier Interpretation. Senior Honors Thesis. The Ohio State University.
Giovannoli Jasmine, Martella Diana, Federico Francesca, Pirchio Sabine, & Casagrande Maria. 2020. The Impact of Bilingualism on Executive Functions in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review Based on the PRISMA Method. Frontiers in Psychology 11. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.574789
Grice, Paul. 1975. Logic and conversation. In P. Cole & J. Morgan (Eds.). Syntax and Semantics 3: Speech acts: 41-58.
Grinstead, John, Kirk, Sadler, Pratt, Amy, & Arrieta-Zamudio, Ana. to appear. Predicting Scalar Implicature Interpretations from Lexical Knowledge. Journal of Speech, Language and Hearing Research.
Grinstead, John, Oates, Morgan, Padilla-Reyes, Ramón, & Nieves-Rivera, Melissa. 2018. Distributive and Collective Quantifier Relationships in the Lexicon: Inhibition, Implicature & Entailment. Poster presented at the Boston University Conference on Language Development.
Grinstead, John, Ortiz-Ramírez, Pedro, Carreto-Guadarrama, Ximena, Arrieta-Zamudio, Ana, Pratt, Amy, Cantú-Sánchez, Myriam, Lefcheck, Jonathan, & Melamed, David. 2022. Piecewise Structural Equation Modeling of the Quantity Implicature in Child Language. Language and Speech. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1177/00238309211066086
Grinstead, John, Padilla-Reyes, Ramón, & Nieves-Rivera, Melissa. 2021. A Collective-Distributive Pragmatic Scale and the Developing Lexicon. Language Learning and Development, 17(1): 48-66.
Grinstead, John, Padilla-Reyes, Ramón, Oates, Morgan, & Nieves Rivera, Melissa. under submission. Piecewise Structural Equation Modeling of the Collective Implicature in Child Language. Language Acquisition.
Gualmini, Andrea, Hulsey, Sarah, Hacquard, Valentine, & Fox, Danny. 2008. The Question-Answer Requirement for scope assignment. Natural Language Semantics. 16: 205-237.
Gutierrez-Rexach, Javier. 2001. The Semantics of Spanish Plural Existential Determiners and the Dynamics of Judgment Types. Probus 13(1): 113-154.
Gutierrez-Rexach, Javier. 2010. Varieties of Indefinites in Spanish. Language and Linguistics Compass: 680-693.
Kaup, Barbara, Kelter, Stephanie, & Habel, Christopher. 2002. Representing Referents of Plural Expressions and Resolving Plural Anaphors. Language and Cognitive Processes 17(4): 405-450.
Kramer, Joel, Mungas, Dan, Possin, Katherine, Rankin, Katherine, Boxer, Adam, Rosen, Howard, Widmeyer, Mary. 2014. NIH EXAMINER: Conceptualization and Development of an Executive Function Battery. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 20(1): 11-19.
Hanlon, C. 1986. Acquisition of Set-Relational Quantifiers in Early Childhood. Genetic, Social and General Psychology Monographs 113(2): 213-264.
Hoff, Erika, Rumiche, Rosario, Burridge, Andrea, Ribot, K., & Welsh, Stephanie. 2014. Expressive Vocabulary Development in Children from Bilingual and Monolingual Homes: A Longitudinal Study from Two to Four Years. Early Childhood Research Quarterly 29: 433-444. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecresq.2014.04.012
Horn, Laurence. 1972. On the Semantic Properties of Logical Operators in English. Doctoral Dissertation. UCLA.
Horn, Laurence. 1989. A Natural History of Negation. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
MacDonald, Maryellen, Pearlmutter, Neal, & Seidenberg, Mark. 1994. Syntactic Ambiguity Resolution as Lexical Ambiguity resolution. In C. Clifton, Jr., L. Frazier, & K. Rayner (Eds.), Perspectives on Sentence Processing: 123–153.
Miyake, Akira, Friedman, Naomi., Emerson, Michael, Witzki, Alexander, & Howerter, Amy 2000. The Unity and Diversity of Executive Functions and their Contributions to Complex 'Frontal Lobe' Tasks: A Latent Variable Analysis. Cognitive Psychology 41(1): 49-
Novick, Jared, Trueswell, John, & Thompson-Schill, Sharon. 2005. Cognitive Control and Parsing: Reexamining the Role of Broca’s Area in Sentence Comprehension. Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience 5: 263–281. https://doi.org/10.3758/CABN.5.3.263
Oates, Morgan. 2017. Competence and Performance in Distributive/Collective Interpretations of Quantifiers in Child English and Spanish. Senior Honors Thesis. The Ohio State University.
Paap Kenneth, Johnson, Hunter, Sawi Oliver. 2015. Bilingual Advantages in Executive Functioning Either do not Exist or are Restricted to Very Specific and Undetermined Circumstances. Cortex 69: 265-78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cortex.2015.04.0
Padilla-Reyes, Ramón, Grinstead, John, & Nieves-Rivera, Melissa. 2016. Development of a Collective- Distributive Pragmatic Scale. Paper presented at the Boston University Conference on Language Development.
Padilla-Reyes, Ramón. 2018. Connections among scales, plurality and intensionality in Spanish. Doctoral Dissertation. The Ohio State University.
Pagliarini, Elena, Fiorin, Gaetano, & Dotlačil, Jakub. 2012. The Acquisition of Distributivity in Pluralities. Proceedings of the Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development 2: 387-399.
Paradis, Johanne. 2011. Individual Differences in Child English Second Language Acquisition: Comparing Child-Internal and Child-External Factors. Linguistic Approaches to Bilingualism 1(3): 213-237.
Pearson, Barbara, Fernandez, Sylvia, & Oller, D.Kimbrough. 1993. Lexical Development in Bilingual Infants and Toddlers: Comparison to Monolingual Norms. Language Learning 7.
Pratt, Amy, Grinstead, John, Ortiz-Ramírez, Pedro, Arrieta-Zamudio, Ana, Cantú-Sánchez, Myriam, Carreto- Guadarrama, Ximena, & Flores-Avalos, Blanca. 2019. Simultaneous vs. Consecutive Action and Implicatures. Paper presented at the 43rd Boston University Conference on Language Development.
Preacher, Kristopher, Hayes, Andrew. 2008. Asymptotic and Resampling Strategies for Assessing and Comparing Indirect Effects in Multiple Mediator Models. Behavior Research Methods 40: 879–891. https://doi.org/10.3758/BRM.40.3.879
Roberts, Craige. 2003. Uniqueness in Definite Noun Phrases. Linguistics & Philosophy, 26(3), 287-350.
Syrett, Kristen, & Musolino, Julien. 2013. Collectivity, distributivity and the interpretation of numerical expressions in child and adult language. Language Acquisition: A Journal of Developmental Linguistics, 20(4), 259-291.
Syrett, Kristen, Austin, Jennifer, Sánchez, Liliana, Germak, Christina, Lingwall, Anna, Perez-Cortes, Silvia, Arias-Amaya, Anthony, & Baker, Hannah. 2017 a. The influence of conversational context and the developing lexicon on the calculation of scalar implicatures: Insights from Spanish-English Bilingual Children. Linguistic Approaches to Bilingualism 7: 230-264. https://doi.org/10.1075/lab.14019.syr
Syrett, Kristen, Lingwall, Anne, Perez-Cortes, Silvia, Austin, Jennifer, Sánchez, Liliana, Baker, Hannah, Germak, Christina, Arias-Amaya, Anthony. 2017 b. Differences between Spanish monolingual and Spanish- English bilingual children in their calculation of entailment-based scalar implicatures. Glossa: A Journal of General Linguistics 2: 1–19. https://doi.org/10.5334/gjgl.76
Thordardottir Elin. 2011. The relationship between bilingual exposure and vocabulary development. International Journal of Bilingualism 15(4): 426-445. https://doi.org/10.1177/1367006911403202
Trueswell, John, & Tanenhaus, Michael. 1994. Toward a Lexicalist Framework of Constraint-Based Syntactic Ambiguity Resolution. In C. Clifton, Jr., L. Frazier, & K. Rayner
(Eds.), Perspectives on sentence processing: 155–179.
Copyright (c) 2022 Anne Lingwall Odio, John Grinstead
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.