Evidence for Sonority-Driven Stress
Abstract
We argue that there is no adequate evidence for ‘sonority-driven stress’, building on Shih (2018a,b), and disagreeing with Kenstowicz (1997), de Lacy (2002a, 2004, 2006), and others. More precisely, we argue that there is no phonological mechanism that induces metrical structure to deviate from its default position for reasons that involve the direct interaction of segmental sonority and foot form. After reviewing the history of sonority-driven stress theory, we identify two broad issues with extant evidence: the lack of methodological reliability, and misattribution of cause. We argue that impressionistic descriptions of sonority-driven stress are not reliable, in the technical sense of evidentiary validity. We further argue that apparent sonority-sensitivity in foot form is a side-effect of either allophony or minor syllable behavior.Keywords
phonology, metrical structure, sonority-driven stress, sonority, stress, evidenceReferences
Adenwala, Mridula. 1965. The structural analysis of the phonology and morphemics of Gujarati. PhD dissertation, State University of New York at Buffalo.
Bianco, Violet M. 1998. Stress assignment in Halkomelem-Cowichan roots. In Dawn Bates (ed.). Papers for the 33rd International Conference on Salish and Neighboring Languages. University of Washington, Seattle. 60-76.
Blankenhorn, Virginia. 1981. Pitch, quantity and stress in Munster Irish. Éigse 18: 225-250.
Blum, Eileen. 2018. Allophony-driven stress in Munster Irish. Ms., Rutgers University, New Jersey. https://www.pauldelacy.net/k.php?x=B18
Bowers, Dustin. 2019. Positional vs. sonority-driven stress in Gujarati: New experimental evidence. Phonological Data and Analysis 1.1: 1-28. https://doi.org/10.3765/pda.v1art1.19
Campbell, George L. & Gareth King. 2011. Concise compendium of the world’s languages. 2nd edn. London & New York: Routledge.
Cardona, George. 1965. A Gujarati reference grammar. Philadelphia: The University of Pennsylvania Press.
Cardona, George & Babu Suthar. 2003. Gujarati. In George Cardona & Dhanesh Jain (eds.). The Indo-Aryan languages. London & New York: Routledge, 722-765.
Carpenter, Angela. 2006. Aquisition of a natural versus an unnatrual stress system. PhD dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
Castrén, M. Alexander. 1854. Grammatik der samojedischen Sprachen. St Petersburg: Buchdruckerei der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften.
Cheliah, Shobhana L. & Willem J. de Reuse. 2011. Handbook of descriptive linguistic fieldwork. Dordrecht: Springer.
Chen, Chun-Mei. 2009a. Documenting Paiwan phonology: issues in segments and non-stress prosodic features. Concentric: Studies in Linguistics 35: 193-223.
Chen, Chun-Mei. 2009b. The phonetics of Paiwan word-level prosody. Language and Linguistics 10: 593-625.
Crowhurst, Megan J. & Lev Michael. 2005. Iterative footing and prominence–drive stress in Nanti (Kampa). Language 81: 47-95.
Davies, John. 1980. Kobon phonology. Canberra: Australian National University.
Davies, John. 1981. Kobon. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
de Lacy, Paul & John Kingston. 2013. Synchronic explanation. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 31: 287-355.
de Lacy, Paul & Patrik Bye. 2008. Metrical influences on lenition and fortition. In Joaquim de Carvalho, Tobias Scheer, and Philippe Ségéral (eds.). Lenition and Fortition. Studies in Generative Grammar. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 173-206.
de Lacy, Paul. 2002a. The formal expression of markedness. PhD dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
de Lacy, Paul. 2002b. The interaction of tone and stress in Optimality Theory. Phonology 19: 1-32.
de Lacy, Paul. 2004. Markedness conflation in Optimality Theory. Phonology 21: 145-199.
de Lacy, Paul. 2006. Markedness: reduction and preservation in phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
de Lacy, Paul. 2007. The interaction of tone, sonority, and prosodic structure. In Paul de Lacy (ed.). The Cambridge handbook of phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 281-307.
de Lacy, Paul. 2009. Phonological evidence. In Steve Parker (ed.). Phonological argumentation: Essays on evidence and motivation. Equinox Publications, 43-78.
de Lacy, Paul. 2014. Evaluating evidence for stress systems. In Harry van der Hulst (ed.). Word stress: theoretical and typological issues. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 149-193.
Dobrovolsky, Michael. 1999. The phonetics of Chuvash stress: implications for phonology. In John J. Ohala, Yoko Hasegawa, Manjari Ohala, Daniel Granville & Ashlee C. Bailey (eds.). Proceedings of the 14th International Conference of Phonetic Sciences. Berkeley, CA: University of California, Berkeley, Linguistics Department, 539-542.
Doctor, Raimond. 2004. A grammar of Gujarati. Munich: Lincom.
Dum-Tragut, Jasmine. 2009. Armenian: modern Eastern Armenian. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Dunn, Michael. 1999. A grammar of Chukchi. Doctoral dissertation, Australian National University.
Foley, William A. 1991. The Yimas language of New Guinea. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Foreman, Velma & Helen Marten. 1973. Yessan-Mayo phonemes. In Alan Healey (ed.). Phonologies of Three Languages of Papua New Guinea. Ukarumpa: Summer Institute of Linguistics. 79-108.
Fry, D. B. 1955. Duration and intensity as physical correlates of linguistic stress. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 27: 765-768.
Garellek, M., & White, J. 2012. Stress correlates and vowel targets in Tongan. UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 110: 65-85.
Gordon, M. 2004. A phonological and phonetic study of word-level stress in Chickasaw. International Journal of American Linguistics 70: 1-32.
Gordon, Matthew & Ayla Applebaum. 2010. Acoustic correlates of stress in Turkish. Journal of the International Phonetic Association 40: 35-58.
Gordon, Matthew & Latifa Nafi. 2012. Acoustic correlates of stress and pitch accent in Tashlhiyt Berber. Journal of Phonetics 40: 706-724.
Gussman, Edmund. 2002. Phonology: analysis and theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Haghverdi, Vartan. 2016. Armenian schwa: a phonetic and phonological analysis. MA thesis, Rutgers University, New Jersey.
Hajdú, Péter. 1964. Samoiedica. Nyelvtudoma´nyi Közleme´nyek 66: 397-405.
Halle, Morris & Jean-Roger Vergnaud. 1987. An essay on stress. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Hayes, Bruce. 1995. Metrical stress theory: principles and case studies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hayes, Bruce. 1989. Compensatory lengthening in moraic phonology. Linguistic Inquiry 20: 253-306.
Helimski, Eugene. 1998. Nganasan. In Daniel Abondolo (ed.). The Uralic languages. London & New York: Routledge, 480-515.
Hickey, Raymond. 2011. The dialects of Irish: study of a changing landscape. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Hickey, Raymond. 2014. The sound structure of Modern Irish. Berlin & Boston: De Gruyter Mouton.
Hyman, Larry. 1985. A theory of phonological weight. Dordrecht: Foris.
Kager, René. 2007. Feet and metrical stress. In Paul de Lacy (ed.). The Cambridge Handbook of Phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 195-227.
Kenstowicz, Michael. 1997. Quality-sensitive stress. Rivista di Linguistica 9: 157-187.
Khachatryan, Amalia. 1988. Zhamanakakits hayereni hnchuytabanutyun (Phonology of contemporary Armenian). Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA Hratarakchutyun.
Ladefoged, Peter. 2003. Phonetic data analysis: an introduction to fieldwork and instrumental techniques. Blackwell Publishing.
Lieberman, Philip. 1960. Some acoustic correlates of word stress in American English. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 32: 451-454.
Lima, Stella Telles Pereira. 1995. A língua Umutina: “um sopro de vida”. MA thesis, Universidade Federal de Pernambuco (UFPA), Recife, Brazil.
Lin, Yen-Hwei. 1998. On minor syllables. In Osamu Fujimura, Brian D. Joseph & Bohumil Palek (eds). Proceedings of LP’98: Item order in language and speech. Prague: The Karolinum Press, 163-183.
Lublinskaya, Marina, Valentine Goussev & Tatiana Sherstinova. 2000. Nganasan multimedia dictionary: a collection of audio material in the Nganasan language. Demo version.
Masica, Colin P. 1991. The Indo–Aryan languages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Master, Alfred. 1925. Stress accent in Modern Gujarati. Journal of the Bombay Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society 1: 76-94.
McGarrity, Laura. 2003. Constraints on patterns of primary and secondary stress. PhD dissertation, Indiana University.
Mistry, P. J. 1997. Gujarati phonology. In A. S. Kaye (ed.). Phonologies of Asia and Africa (including the Caucasus). Vol. 2. Winona Lake, Ind.: Eisenbrauns, 653-673.
Modi, Bharati. 2013. Some issues in Gujarati phonology (Languages of the World 44). Muenchen: Lincom.
Ó Cuív, Brian. 1944. The Irish of West Muskerry, Co. Cork. Dublin: Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies.
Ó Sé, Diarmuid. 1989. Contributions to the study of word stress in Irish. Ériu 40: 147-178.
Ó Sé, Diarmuid. 2008. Word stress in Munster Irish. Éigse 36: 87-112.
Oakden, Chris. 2018. Tone and stress in Lithuanian. Ms., Rutgers University, New Jersey.
Owens, Jonathan. 1985. A grammar of Harar Oromo (Northeastern Ethiopia). Hamburg: Helmut Buske Verlag.
Payne, Judith. 1990. Asheninca stress patterns. In Doris L. Payne (ed.). Amazonian linguistics: studies in lowland South American languages. Austin: University of Texas Press, 185-209.
Pennington, Ryan. 2013. Ma Manda phonology. MA thesis, Graduate Institute of Applied Linguistics, Dallas.
Peterson, Gordon E. & Ilse Lehiste. 1960. Duration of syllable nuclei in English. JASA 32: 693-703.
Prince, Alan & Paul Smolensky. 2004. Optimality Theory: constraint interaction in generative grammar. Malden, Mass. & Oxford: Blackwell.
Prince, Alan. 1983. Relating to the grid. Linguistic Inquiry 14: 19-100.
Prokofjev, G.N. 1937. Nganasanskij (tavgijskij) dialekt. In Iazyki i pis ‘mennost’ samoedskii i finno-ugorskii narodov. Moscow & Leningrad: Učpedgiz, 53-74.
Raisin, Ezer. 2017. The stress-encapsulation universal and phonological modularity. Ms. MIT. https://www.pauldelacy.net/k.php?x=R17
Ray, William J. 2009. Methods towards a science of behavior and experience. Belmont: Wadsworth.
Ross, Malcolm. 1995. Takia. In Darrell T. Tryon (ed.). Comparative Austronesian Dictionary: An Introduction to Austronesian Studies. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter, 677-686.
Ross, Malcolm. 2002. Takia. In John Lynch, Malcolm Ross & Terry Crowley (eds.). The Oceanic Languages. Richmond: Curzon Press, 216-248.
Ross, Malcolm. 2009. Loanwords in Takia, an Oceanic language of Papua New Guinea. In Martin Haspelmath & Uri Tadmor (eds.). Loanwords in the World’s Languages: A Comparative Handbook. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 747-770.
Sakayan, Dora. 2007. Eastern Armenian for the English-speaking world: a contrastive approach. Yerevan: Yerevan State University Press.
Schiering, René & Harry van der Hulst. 2010. Word accent systems in the languages of Asia. In Rob Goedemans, Harry van der Hulst & Ellen van Zanten (eds.). A survey of word accentual patterns in the languages of the world. Berlin: Mouton De Gruyter, 509-613.
Schlie, Perry & Ginny Schlie. 1993. A Kara phonology. In John M. Clifton (ed.). Data papers on New Guinea linguistics: Phonologies of Austronesian languages 2. Papua New Guinea: SIL Academic Publications, 99-130.
Schlie, Perry. 1996. Kara organised phonology data. Ukarumpa: Summer Institute of Linguistics. Available at https://www.pauldelacy.net/k.php?x=S96
Scorza, David. 1973. Phonemes of the Au language. Ukarumpa: Summer Institute of Linguistics. Available at https://www.pauldelacy.net/k.php?x=S73
Scorza, David. 1976. Au language: Word, phrase, clause. SIL Language and Culture Archives.
Scorza, David. 1985. A sketch of Au morphology and syntax. Papers in New Guinea Linguistics 22: 215-273.
Scorza, David. 1992. Au organised phonology data. Ukarumpa: Summer Institute of Linguistics. Available at https://www.pauldelacy.net/k.php?x=S92
Shih, Shu-hao. 2016. Sonority-driven stress does not exist. In Gunnar Ólafur Hansson, Ashley Farris-Trimble, Kevin McMullin & Douglas Pulleyblank (eds.). Supplemental Proceedings of the 2015 Annual Meeting on Phonology. Washington, DC: Linguistic Society of America. http://dx.doi.org/10.3765/amp.v3i0.3666
Shih, Shu-hao. 2018a. On the existence of sonority-driven stress in Gujarati. Phonology 35: 327-364. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0952675718000064
Shih, Shu-hao. 2018b. Non-moraic schwa: Phonology and phonetics. Doctoral Dissertation, Rutgers University. https://ling.rutgers.edu/images/dissertations/Shih-thesis-2018.pdf
Skorik, Petr Ja. 1961. Grammatika čukotskogo Jazyka, tom 1. Leningrad: Nauka.
Skorik, Petr Ja. 1977. Grammatika čukotskogo Jazyka, tom 2. Leningrad: Nauka.
Tabain, Marija, Janet Fletcher & Andrew Butcher. 2014. Lexical stress in Pitjantjatjara. Journal of Phonetics 42: 52-66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wocn.2013.11.005
Tereschenko, N.M. 1979. Nganasanskii iazyk. Leningrad: Nauka.
Tsygankin, P. J. & C. Z. Debaev. 1975. Očerk sravnitel’noj grammatiki mordovskix (mokšanskogo i erz’anskogo) literaturnix jazykov. Saransk: Mordovskij gosudarstvennyj universitet imeni N.P. Ogareva.
Turner, Ralph L. 1921. Gujarati phonology. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland 3: 329-365.
van Oostendorp, Marc. 2000. Phonological projection: a theory of feature content and prosodic structure. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Vaux, Bert. 1998. The phonology of Armenian. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Vaysman, Olga. 2009. Segmental alternations and metrical theory. PhD dissertation, MIT.
Wetzels, Leo & Sergio Meira. 2010. A survey of South American stress systems. In Rob Goedemans, Harry van der Hulst & Ellen van Zanten (eds.). A Survey of Word Accentual Patterns in the Languages of the World. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter, 313-380.
Wetzels, W. Leo, Stella Telles & Ben Hermans. 2014. Onsets and syllable prominence in Umutina. DELTA: Documentação de Estudos em Lingüística Teórica e Aplicada 30: 703-720.
Yeh, Shih-chi Stella. 2011. Issues in Paiwan phonology. PhD dissertation, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu, Taiwan.
Zec, Draga. 2007. The syllable. In Paul de Lacy (ed.). The Cambridge handbook of phonology. Cambridge University Press, 161-194.
Published
How to Cite
Downloads
Copyright (c) 2019 Shu-hao Shih, Paul de Lacy
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
